The Last of Us Takes No.1: The 100 Greatest Games List and the Rubric Nobody Will Publish
The No.1 spot on the list of the 100 greatest video games of all time has jus...
The No.1 spot on the list of the 100 greatest video games of all time has just been handed to a title that even its detractors refuse to call bad. The Last of Us topped the ranking published by Kinda Funny Games. Under the comment section, three camps went to war: the Part I loyalists, the Part II advocates, and a third group dragging Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice into the argument as a shield. None of them argued about whether the game was good. They argued about what the word “good” means.
I took this assignment for a different reason entirely: it reached me under an esports label. Across the entire body of content there is not a single team, not a single tournament, not a single patch, not a single player. It is a single-player title with no live-service lifecycle, no competitive ladder, no tournament server. That mislabel is the real story, and I will come back to it mid-article, because it is not an administrative detail — it is a data problem.
But first, the moment itself. Kinda Funny Games — the outlet founded by Greg Miller, raised on podcasts and North American creator culture — published a list of the 100 greatest games. First place went to The Last of Us. The reaction was immediate and it split in two directions. One side said: obviously, nothing to discuss. The other said: if the criterion is gameplay systems, Part II is clearly superior to Part I; if the criterion is historical influence, other titles must be named; and if the criterion is designed difficulty, Sekiro is the answer.
The notable thing is that all three sides are right. And that is exactly why this ranking cannot be wrong. A ranking built on an ambiguous rubric can never be proven false — it can only be rejected. I say what fans are afraid to hear, and they hate me for it.
Context: a content genre, not a measuring instrument
The Last of Us launched on 14 June 2026, developed by Naughty Dog, exclusive to PlayStation. It arrived after the Uncharted run and inherited nearly the entire cinematic grammar that studio had spent years polishing: over-the-shoulder camera, long takes, slow pacing, dialogue layered over action, and an ending that denies the player a choice. Part II launched on 19 June 2026, while the world was in lockdown.
That second date is not a footnote. The Last of Us Part II is a game about a pandemic released in the middle of a pandemic, and judged by people in an emotional state entirely different from the one it was designed to exploit. A trophy born in a pandemic grows into an unanswered question. Nobody in 2026 could sit still long enough to enjoy a story about systemic loss, and nobody could deny that the story was told with tremendous control. Both things are true, and they do not cancel out.
Then there is Clair Obscur: Expedition 33. The original article builds a rhetorical ladder: from simple products such as Pong to modern games such as Clair Obscur: Expedition 33. That ladder has two problems. First, it uses a 2026 release as the endpoint of the medium's entire history — a recency-bias marker. Second, it frames industry history as a straight line from simple to complex, when the real history is a series of forks, some of which went backwards and some of which died.
A ranking like this is not a measurement tool. It is a content genre. Low production cost, short lifespan, high engagement, and all of its value sitting in the comment section. I learned that at fourteen, when my first LA Galaxy piece pulled more than twelve hundred reads purely because the headline poked a costly signing. That piece was not good. It was just aimed correctly. In this industry, aimed correctly beats good.
I do not predict the future; I excavate the past and throw it in your face — and the past I am throwing this time is simple: every “greatest of all time” list is a referendum with no voter roll.
Core: four rubrics on one list, none of them disclosed
What makes this ranking worth analysing is not the top slot. It is that at least four different rubrics are being applied to one list, and none of them comes with a stated weighting.
The first rubric is mechanics. This camp argues that on combat systems, on resource loops, on how enemy AI responds to player choice, Part II beats Part I on nearly every axis. They are right. Part II gives players more options, more states, and — most importantly — it lets players create situations the designers never anticipated. That is the standard systems analysts use to measure depth.
The second rubric is narrative. This camp argues Part I is a closed story: it has a beginning, it has a price, it has an ending the player has to carry. Part II is an open story, deliberately uncomfortable, and the discomfort is the point rather than the flaw. They are also right. Part II's ending does not satisfy, and it was not designed to.
The third rubric is historical influence. This camp argues Part I reset the standard for AAA storytelling for nearly a decade, that it proved a video game could make players cry without long cutscenes. Still right. And the Uncharted-to-The-Last-of-Us lineage cited in the original piece is precisely the evidence of how that influence operates: not by producing copies, but by raising the bar for everyone who came after.
And the fourth rubric, the one nobody names, is production value. This is the rubric the list actually uses, without saying so. A list run by a Western, creator-led, console-first outlet will always favour titles with large visual budgets, performance capture, and orchestral scores — because that is the easiest thing to see and the easiest thing to agree on. Deep systems have to be played. Historical influence has to be read. A beautiful shot is visible to anyone in thirty seconds.
That is why The Last of Us wins. It is a game that can be rated highly by someone who has never played it.

I am not saying that as an insult. I am saying it as a structural observation. A ranking that wants to survive has to manufacture minimum consensus, and minimum consensus in games right now is built on image and emotion, not systems. That is why the same list will never put a title like Sekiro on top, however technically superior its combat is. Sekiro demands investment from the player. A ranking demands agreement from the reader.
One detail in the original piece is worth preserving because it incriminates itself: the article records the question of whether the list evaluates by gameplay quality, popularity, or influence. The question is raised and never answered. When a publication asks itself about its own rubric and leaves it hanging, that is a sign the rubric never existed — not that it was carefully hidden.
Fair play is what winning teams use to soothe losing teams. In ranking language it has another name: objective criteria. And objective criteria, when undisclosed, is just a polite term for personal taste.
There is one more device worth naming. The original piece notes that even detractors concede Part I is one of the most outstanding games in history. Sounds harmless. Structurally, it is a consensus-manufacturing mechanism: it converts a split into an apparent near-consensus by conceding a weaker claim. Nobody objects to the weak claim, so nobody notices the strong claim — the No.1 slot — is still contested.
The comparison I keep making, and still believe
In esports, whenever a team wins a title with slow, defensive, controlling play, the community splits instantly. One side says: a title is a title. The other says: winning that way damages the competition. Neither is wrong, because they are measuring different things — one measures outcome, the other measures
