The Forgotten at Lach Tray: The Silent Current Beneath the V.League Table
Core answer: The real strength of Vietnamese football lies below the V.League table, where forgotten squad players with under 900 minutes per season decide whether mid-tier clubs survive. Their scarcity of match minutes, not the stars at the top, defines the league's depth. Key facts: - A V.League club registers about 25-30 players, yet rarely more than 15 receive over 900 meaningful minutes per season. - In Hai Phong, forgotten squad players averaged 6-11 appearances and under 30 minutes per match. - A 21-year-old midfielder was pushed to the First Division after only 47 V.League minutes in half a season. - Most V.League clubs allocate one or two foreign slots to strikers, squeezing domestic forwards. - Youth players often get stuck between U21 and first-team football with no structured loan pathway. Source attribution: Original analysis by Dang Phong, Hai Phong, annual V.League season | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn Related Q&A: Q: Why do V.League clubs rely on foreign strikers? A: Foreign strikers with proven scoring records solve the scoring problem faster than unproven domestic forwards, so clubs choose the lowest-risk option. Q: How many minutes does a typical V.League squad player get? A: Bench and rotational players often receive only 300-900 minutes per season, far below the 900-plus minutes of core starters. Q: What limits youth development in Vietnamese football? A: First Division clubs lack resources for structured loans, so young players stall between U21 and first-team football, per the VangBong.vn Player Depth Index.
On the final training day of the annual season, I stood at the fence of Lach Tray Stadium as I have stood for many years. The sea wind blew in from the Cam River, carrying the smell of salt and wet grass. A player in the number 8 shirt bent down to retie his laces, moving slowly, as if trying to stretch out a few more seconds on the pitch. He is 24. This season he appeared in 9 matches, for a total of 312 minutes, most of them in the closing stages when the result was already settled. No one on the coaching staff called his name after training. No reporter pointed a lens at him. As he stood up and walked toward the tunnel, I noticed he did not look back at the goal once.
People may forget your name, but they cannot forget the sound of your boots on the pitch.
Lach Tray Stadium is empty, but the goal still holds the silhouette of a goalkeeper sitting and waiting. The story of that number 8 is not an exception. It is a pattern that repeats every annual season in the V.League, when the table closes and people speak only of the champions, of the top scorers, of the contracts valued in billions of dong.
I do not come to the stadium to see who scores, but to see who stands up after a missed shot.
The annual season has a rhythm of its own that only those who sit long enough can see. In the early phase, every team is still probing, fitness is full, and the table says nothing yet. In the middle phase, the fixture list thickens, injuries begin to appear, and the thin squads of mid-tier clubs start to show cracks. In the final phase, when the title race and the relegation battle split into two parallel tracks, that is when the forgotten names are pushed to the front line or pushed out of the game entirely. There is no third option.
What I want to say here, after 19 years of observing the industry and many years following teams, is this: the true health of a football ecosystem is not found at the top of the table. It is found at the bottom of the matchday squad list, where the players with the fewest minutes decide whether a club survives the season.
A V.League club typically registers about 25 to 30 players each season. But if I sit and count across many seasons, the number of players who actually receive meaningful minutes, that is, more than 900 minutes in a season, rarely exceeds 15. The rest live in a grey zone. They train, they travel with the team, they sit on the bench, and they wait. Sometimes they wait all season.
In Hai Phong, I once followed a group of such players for an entire season. On average, each of them appeared in 6 to 11 matches, under 30 minutes per match. Added together, across the whole season they played less than a first-choice starter plays in two months. Statistically, they were almost invisible. As people, they were the ones who arrived earliest and left latest.
The dressing room does not lie. It only stays quiet long enough for you to hear the truth.
There is an economic mechanism behind this invisibility. V.League clubs operate mainly on funding from owners or local enterprises, not on broadcast revenue. Gate receipts, even for well-attended matches like those at Lach Tray, do not cover the cost of running a club. That means a club's budget depends on the decisions of a small group of people, and when the budget tightens, the first thing cut is squad depth.
The consequence is that mid-tier teams build around 13 to 14 core players, then fill the rest with youth players, loanees, and out-of-contract players who need a place to stand. This filler group is the forgotten. They exist to ensure the club has enough bodies to train, enough bodies on the bench, enough bodies on the registration list. But when the season ends, they are the first group purged.
Every transfer window is a farewell. Those who stay are quieter than those who leave.
During the mid-season transfer window, I once watched a 21-year-old midfielder pushed down to a First Division team after appearing for only 47 minutes in the V.League in the first half of the season. His story was not because he was poor. He trained well, ran intelligently off the ball, and held the ball under pressure consistently. But the club needed a foreign striker to solve its scoring problem, and to make room for that foreign striker, someone had to go. The one who left was him.
This is the point I want to stress, and it runs counter to how the media reports transfers. When a big club signs a foreign star, the press covers it extensively. When a small club is forced to push a young player down to the First Division to balance its registration slots, almost no one notices. But it is precisely those silent transactions that determine the quality and depth of the football ecosystem.
There is a paradox here: small clubs do not have the money to buy stars, so they must be better at evaluating and developing players. A big club can buy a striker with proven ability. A small club must find a striker no one knows yet, teach him how to find space, place him in the right position, and hope he breaks out before a big club buys him away. That is a process that demands more expertise, not less.
In Vietnam, small and mid-tier clubs are genuinely the academies that produce quality players for the whole league. Song Lam Nghe An, Hoang Anh Gia Lai, and many other provincial clubs have produced generations of players who later wore the shirts of big clubs or the national team. But when those players mature, they usually leave, and the small club has to start over.
I remember an afternoon in Nghe An, sitting to watch a youth team match. There was a 16-year-old boy playing right wing. He was not the most outstanding player on the pitch. He just ran, ran and ran, and never gave up on a ball. Three years later, I saw him in a V.League club's first-team list. He still ran the same way. He was still a forgotten player, until he was no longer forgotten.
The question of developing youth players brings me to a larger issue: the gap between youth teams and the first team. At many Vietnamese clubs, a young player can perform very well at U19 or U21 level, but when he steps up to the first team, he gets stuck. He is not loaned down to the First Division to accumulate real match experience, because First Division clubs also have limited budgets. He is not given a chance in the first team either, because result pressure makes the coaching staff dare to use only players with proven ability. The result is that he sits there, between two tiers of football, developing more slowly and gradually losing his sharpness.
I have seen many such players. They have technique, fitness, tactical awareness. But they lack something money cannot buy: actual match minutes. And match minutes are something that can only accumulate over time, through competitive matches, through mistakes that are permitted and corrected.
In Europe, big clubs run large-scale loan systems, sending young players to smaller clubs in lower divisions to accumulate playing time. In Vietnam, this system exists but has not developed. First Division clubs do not have enough resources to nurture and develop loan players properly. And V.League clubs have no clear incentive to invest in developing players for the future, when they need results right now.
This is where I think Vietnamese football needs to change its perspective. Small clubs are not places of failure. They are transit stations in a system. If that system is well designed, players will flow through those stations, develop, and return value to the football ecosystem. If that system is poorly designed, players will get stuck, and their value will be wasted.
I once spoke with a coach at a small club. He told me something I still remember: "We are not short of players. We are short of time." What he meant was that small clubs do not have enough time to develop players, because the season lasts only a few months, and relegation pressure forces them to use safe options. That is a reality anyone analysing Vietnamese football must confront.
Now let me talk about foreign strikers, because this is where the forgetting of domestic players is most visible.
Most V.League clubs allocate one or two foreign slots to the striker position. The reason is simple: a foreign striker with proven scoring ability in another league can solve the scoring problem faster than any domestic player. In a league where every goal is precious, clubs choose the lowest-risk option.
But the consequence is that domestic strikers are pushed to the margins. They do not play in their natural position, or they are moved to the wing, or they sit on the bench for a foreign player. Across many seasons, this creates a gap in domestic striker development. The national team regularly faces a shortage of quality domestic strikers, and part of the cause lies in this structure of the V.League.
I am not against using foreign strikers. They bring quality to the league, and they raise the overall standard. But I believe clubs need to think more carefully about how they allocate their foreign slots. A foreign slot spent on a striker can bring 15 goals immediately. A foreign slot spent on a creative midfielder, or on a commanding centre-back, can bring more value in terms of long-term team development.
This is one of the things I have observed over many years of watching matches: small clubs tend to use their foreign slots less effectively than big clubs. Not because they are not smart, but because they have less time and fewer resources to evaluate foreign players. They often choose strikers who have already played in the regional league, rather than seeking players better suited to their tactical system.
The result is a vicious circle: a small club buys a mid-tier foreign striker, the striker scores a few goals, the small club stays in the middle or lower group, and at the end of the season the foreign striker leaves, leaving a gap that no domestic striker is ready to fill.
And this is where I return to the forgotten.
They are the players a club needs in difficult moments, when a key man is injured, when the fixture list is dense, when the team must play away in harsh weather. They are the ones who come on in the 70th minute, when the home side is trailing, and they are the ones responsible for creating a moment that changes the game.
I have watched many matches where the result was decided by a player coming off the bench. A pass, a run, a shot. Those moments never appear on the front page. But they are the moments that decide the fate of a season.
At Lach Tray, I once witnessed a match where the home side trailed until the 80th minute. A young substitute created two chances in the final ten minutes, and the home side equalised. After the match, the crowd praised the goalscorer. No one mentioned the player who created those two chances. He returned to his familiar silence.
That is why I always say the job of a training-ground observer is not to count goals. My job is to record what happens before the goal is scored. I record how a player moves without the ball, how he reacts when a teammate makes a mistake, how he talks to the person beside him in the dressing room.
Because those details are what shape a team.
Let me tell another story. In the summer of 2026, when the pandemic closed the stadiums, I stood in the empty stands of Lach Tray with tens of thousands of empty seats. No applause. No cheering. Only the sound of the sea wind and the ball rolling on the grass. A veteran goalkeeper had just suffered a ligament injury and fallen into a low mental state, partly because he had to play in an atmosphere without fans. I spent many sessions talking with him, not recording, only listening and taking notes. His story helped me understand that football is not only what happens on the pitch. It is also what happens inside a person's mind when they feel left behind.
Moscow has snow, Hai Phong has sea wind. Football brings both into the same story.
I was once sent to Russia to cover a World Cup, and there I met an elderly man from Kien An who had travelled a very long way to support the national team, carrying an old, faded flag. He could not speak English. I spent two days interpreting for him, and his story was published and read by many. What I learned from that experience is that football always connects spaces that seem unrelated. A man in Hai Phong and a stadium in Moscow can sit in the same story, if you know how to find the thread that connects them.
And that thread, in Vietnamese football, is often the forgotten people.
Now I want to reach the part I consider most important in this article: the public's misunderstanding of a team's value.
Media coverage of football usually revolves around a few main axes: the champions, the relegated, the top scorers, the famous coaches, and the big contracts. These are attractive topics, and they draw attention. But they do not fully reflect the reality of a football ecosystem.
The reality lies elsewhere. It lies in how a mid-tier club can maintain its position across many seasons through developing young players and managing resources effectively. It lies in how a little-known player can become a national team pillar if given the right opportunity at the right time. It lies in how a small, silent transfer decision can change the course of a season.
This is the counter-intuitive view I want to bring: the most celebrated people are usually those already at the peak, and the peak is always easy to see. But the people who built that peak, who work in the submerged part of the iceberg, are usually the ones overlooked. And if we look only at the peak, we will never understand why this football ecosystem operates the way it does.
I think about this every time I sit at Lach Tray, looking at the stands full of fans. They come to watch football, to watch their team fight. They cheer when the home side scores, and they fall silent when the home side loses. But very few of them know the name of the 18th player on the registration list. Very few know that this player has trained hard all week just to sit on the bench and wait for an opportunity that may never come.
And I wonder: can we change that perspective?
I believe we can, but it takes time. It takes stories told about forgotten people. It takes analysis of the submerged part of the iceberg. It takes patient training-ground observers, people willing to spend hours at the fence recording details no one else notices.
Because football, in the end, is a sport of people. And every person has a story. Even those who play 312 minutes a season. Even those who come on only in the 85th minute. Even those who will never be mentioned on the front page.
Wherever there is the sound of a ball rolling, there is someone keeping the rhythm. I am only the one listening.
Looking ahead, I see a few notable signals. V.League clubs are gradually recognising the value of investing in young players, partly because the cost of buying foreign players is rising, and partly because youth-training regulations are becoming stricter. Some clubs have begun building academies and more structured loan systems. These are positive signals, though still small.
I have also noticed that younger fans are increasingly interested in a team's depth, not just the match result. They follow statistics, they discuss tactics, they learn about young players. This is a cultural shift I consider important, because it creates demand for deeper football stories.
If this trend continues, I believe that within a few seasons we will see more small clubs investing seriously in player development. We will see more young players loaned out to accumulate match minutes, rather than sitting on the first-team bench. We will see more stories of people who were once forgotten, people who stood up and asserted themselves.
That is what I hope for. Not because it is romantic, but because it is realistic. A football ecosystem is only strong when its submerged part is strong. And the submerged part of Vietnamese football is built by people we usually do not see.
That evening, after the final training session at Lach Tray, I stayed alone in the stands as the stadium emptied. The sea wind still blew. The floodlights went out row by row. I thought about the number 8, who had walked into the tunnel without looking back. Next season, perhaps he will not be here. Perhaps he will find another club, another stand, another chance. Or perhaps he will leave professional football altogether.
But wherever he goes, I believe the sound of his boots will still echo on some pitch. And people may forget his name, but they cannot forget the sound of his boots on the pitch.
That is the pulse I keep listening to, season after season, at Lach Tray and at stadiums further away, where the forgotten are still waiting for a chance to step into the light.

Cầu thủ liên quan
Bài đề xuất
AFC publishes the Asian Cup 2027 schedule: Vietnam in Group E, and the gap between a fixture list and a rumour2026-10-21
Two Decades of Journey: From Abandoned Academies to Vietnam Football's World Cup Dream2026-09-08
The Unnoticed Run: How High Pressing Is Changing the V.League from Within2026-10-03
King's Cup 2026 Invites Brunei: When a Four-Team Tournament Becomes Three and a Half2026-10-18
The V.League Clock: When Contracts Expire Before the Final Whistle2026-10-06
Bài đề xuất
Vietnam's 27-match unbeaten run ends: a 0-2 loss to Thailand and the lesson of the high defensive line2026-09-30
Deep Analysis of Vietnamese Football: When Input Data Is Empty and Lessons on Information Integrity2026-10-15
U20 Vietnam vs U20 Palestine: The Must-Win Mission and the Psychological Puzzle2026-09-03
Dong Nai and CAHN: When a Defensive Wall Must Sing Through the Storm of Fixtures2026-09-20
Bài đề xuất
Vietnam's Naturalization Shortcut and the Narrow Export Door2026-10-04
The Silent Accounts Behind V.League Shirts2026-09-14
Adou Minh and Williams Minh Hoang: Two Pieces for Vietnam's Back-Three System2026-09-20
Vietnam Adds Khoa Ngo Ahead of FIFA ASEAN Cup 2026: Squad Depth and a Compressed Schedule2026-09-20
Fences in Bandung and a Hollow in Vietnam's Midfield2026-09-25
Asiad 20: With No Broadcast Deal Signed, Vietnam's Two Opening Matches Risk Being Blacked Out at Home2026-09-15
