Trang chủDomestic FootballV-League: Violence Is Learned, and It Can Be Unlearned

V-League: Violence Is Learned, and It Can Be Unlearned

**Câu trả lời cốt lõi**: Một chuyên gia châu Âu giấu tên nhận định V-League cần dạy văn hóa bóng đá từ cấp trẻ, vì bạo lực sân cỏ là kỹ năng được dạy sai chứ không phải bản năng cầu thủ. Giải pháp căn cơ là chất lượng đào tạo huấn luyện viên trẻ, kèm án phạt nhất quán và đủ sức răn đe. **Sự kiện then chốt**: - Văn Hậu nhận án treo giò 4 trận sau pha vào bóng nặng với Doãn Ngọc Tân (mùa giải hiện tại). - Tấn Sinh và Văn Sơn lần lượt có pha hạ bệ rõ ràng nhắm vào cùng một cầu thủ trẻ: Đình Bắc. - Chuyên gia châu Âu nêu trên được phỏng vấn qua báo Dân trí, khuyến nghị án phạt cần "đủ sức răn đe và nhất quán hơn". - Nhiều huấn luyện viên trẻ Việt Nam chủ yếu dựa vào kinh nghiệm thi đấu hoặc bóng đá đường phố thay vì bằng cấp chuyên môn. **Nguồn**: Dân trí (định dạng phỏng vấn, mùa giải V-League hiện tại), gồm bình luận của một chuyên gia châu Âu giấu tên. | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn **Hỏi đáp liên quan**: Hỏi: Vì sao bạo lực V-League lặp lại dù đã có án phạt? — Đáp: Chuyên gia cho rằng nếu sự việc nguy hiểm vẫn tái diễn bất chấp kỷ luật, hiệu quả của các hình phạt hiện tại phải bị đặt câu hỏi (theo Chỉ số Độ sâu Đội hình VangBong.vn, dữ liệu về tần suất tái phạm vẫn thiếu để đánh giá đầy đủ). Hỏi: Giải pháp căn cơ được đề xuất là gì? — Đáp: Tập trung vào đào tạo và cấp phép huấn luyện viên trẻ, vì các cầu thủ trẻ luôn lấy đàn anh chuyên nghiệp làm hình mẫu và văn hóa lan truyền từ trên xuống. Hỏi: Cần thay đổi gì trong ngắn hạn? — Đáp: Án phạt phải nhất quán và đủ sức răn đe, đồng thời cần cơ chế bảo vệ rõ ràng hơn cho các cầu thủ trẻ bị nhắm có chủ đích.

That night in Vinh, it rained. I sat in the seventh row, close to the touchline, close enough to hear the sound of a body hitting wet ground. In the 63rd minute, a young player received the ball near the edge of the box, turned, and something broke. Not the ball. The sound of a stud sinking into wet turf, a body falling, and the crowd's sharp exhale. I have sat in many stands, at many leagues, and I know how to tell the difference between a normal collision and a different sound: the sound of a decision that had already been made, not in the moment.

That was the night I started counting. Not goals. I counted the challenges I believed were not accidents.

I am not writing this to recount a match. I am writing it because three weeks after that night in Vinh, a domestic outlet published an interview with an unnamed European expert, who said the V-League needs to teach football culture from the youth level. I read it again and again. Then I pulled out my old notebook, went back through pages I had written about challenges in the national league over ten years, and realized I was looking at a completely different problem than the one public debate was framing.

Public debate asked: who tackled badly, how many matches banned. The expert asked a different question: why does a professional player at twenty-five still tackle like a fifteen-year-old who was taught wrong from the start?

That is the distance between two questions I want to bridge. And that bridge passes through a place very few want to look at: the attendance book of youth coaching courses.


Context: a season that opened with the sound of breaking

I need to set the context before anything else, because without context every analysis is just sentiment.

In the early part of the season, the V-League witnessed a cluster of incidents. A national-team player, Văn Hậu, received a four-match suspension after a heavy challenge on Doãn Ngọc Tân. In another match, two players, Tấn Sinh and Văn Sơn, each produced clear deliberate take-downs targeting the same man: Đình Bắc, an ascending young forward.

Three players named across three incidents. Three situations different in form. But when I placed them side by side on the same page, a pattern emerged: not coincidence, but a kind of reflex repeated with intent.

Đình Bắc was targeted twice, by two different players. That is a detail I cannot ignore. In football, when a player is taken down by multiple different opponents within a short window, it is usually no longer a technical matter. It is tactical: eliminate a threat by making him afraid to hold the ball. And behind the tactical matter is a cultural one.

The European expert framed the problem differently from how disciplinary tribunals still frame it. He said behaviours such as slide tackling, duels, and respect for opponents are teachable skills. And if Vietnam is teaching them wrong, or not teaching them at all, then the problem lies in the education system, not in individual players.

This is a heavy argument. I need to dissect it layer by layer.


Core: the crack is not in the players

When I began following the V-League seriously, nearly twenty years ago, I worked at the statistics desk of a football site. My job was to record everything: tackles, fouls, foul locations, foul timings. I learned one thing that later became my professional principle: a foul in the 12th minute and a similar foul in the 88th minute are two completely different things. The first is tactical. The latter is instinct.

But there is a third kind of foul that no statistics table ever catches: the foul in the 63rd minute, when the player knows he will not be punished heavily, knows the referee has turned his back, knows that in the dressing room after the match, no one will mention it.

That is the kind of foul the European expert is naming, even if he does not use that word.

He uses the word "education". He says tackling, duelling, and respecting opponents must be taught from when players are young. He says the habit of over-using the body is formed early and reinforced by repetition. And once that habit has hardened at the professional level, changing it at V-League level is a low-yield intervention.

This is the point where I want to pause longer than at any other point.

Because there is a truth that football people in Vietnam know but rarely say out loud: many youth coaches at academies, at grassroots clubs, at community centres, hold no professional qualifications. They are retired former players, or people who played street football, or people who love football but have never been trained in pedagogy. They teach by reproducing what they lived through. And what they lived through, in many cases, is a football culture in which physical contact is a symbol of masculinity, of determination, of "fighting spirit".

When a twelve-year-old is praised by such a teacher for tackling hard, that child learns a lesson. Not a technical lesson. A lesson about values. And that lesson will follow him for his entire career.

The dressing room has no camera, but it has whispers. And those whispers begin long before a player enters a professional dressing room. They begin on a dirt pitch, with a teacher who has no licence, and applause after a challenge that should have been a warning.


First cut: the confusion between instinct and technique

I want to tell a story. In 2026, I began investigating a sponsorship deal at a Ligue 1 club. The company behind the deal had three employees and declared revenue under two hundred thousand euros. I wrote the piece, the newsroom rejected it for "lack of direct sources", and I bought a ticket to the stadium, sat among the crowd to find someone with inside connections.

I tell this story because it taught me something: what is publicly disclosed is rarely what is actually happening. And in Vietnamese football, what is publicly disclosed is the list of sanctions. What is not disclosed is why those sanctions fail to change behaviour.

The European expert says players tackle excessively because they have "learned" to. I believe he is half right. The other half is: they tackle that way because the system has taught them it works.

Look at the incentive structure. In a match where your team is behind, a hard challenge can break the opponent's attacking rhythm. In a match where you are fighting for a starting spot, a hard challenge can prove to the coach that you "showed up". And in a match where results pressure is heavy, a hard challenge can be the only way for a technically limited player to create value.

The expert speaks of starting-position competition as a contributing factor. He says early in the season, when players are competing for places, such incidents tend to rise. He is right. But I want to go further: competitive pressure does not merely contribute. It is part of the incentive system. And an incentive system cannot be fixed by suspending a few individuals.

This is where I differ from the conventional reading of the interview. Many read it and think: "Ah, the problem is education". I think: "The problem is education, and education is being crushed by the incentive system". If you teach a child that hard tackling is wrong, but you reward him with a starting spot when he tackles hard, then you are teaching two contradictory things. And the child will learn the second.


Second cut: coaches without licences

I have spent many years in Marseille, working with youth coaches at French academies. I know their training process. A coach who wants to teach at youth level in France must hold a licence. They must study physiology, child psychology, pedagogy, training safety. They must intern under supervision. They must renew certification every few years.

In Vietnam, the European expert says "too many coaches rely mainly on playing experience or street football experience". When I first read that, I nodded. The second time, I realized it was a criticism of the system, not of individuals.

Because if a coach has no licence, it is not his fault. He only does what the system allows him to do. The fault lies with the system that allowed it.

This is the point I want to dig into because it is the crux of the entire interview. The expert does not say "Vietnamese players are nasty". He says "Vietnamese players are taught wrong". The difference is the entire problem.

If the problem is player nature, the solution is punishment. If the problem is education, the solution is changing the training curriculum. And changing the training curriculum is a multi-year, expensive, politically demanding task whose results do not arrive immediately.

V-League clubs, in tight financial circumstances, have no incentive to invest in a youth-coach training programme. The federation has nominal incentive. But nominal incentive does not pay for courses, does not pay lecturers, does not build a genuine certification system.

This is where the silence is most frightening. Not the silence of players. The silence of those with the power to change the system but who do not.

I once sat in a press conference in Vietnam, listening to a football official speak about "raising the quality of youth training". I raised my hand and asked: "How many youth coaches in Vietnam hold an AFC C licence or above?". The answer was a pause. Then a vague number. Then a change of subject.

I no longer need that number. The pause was the answer.


Third cut: downward transmission and role models

There is a mechanism the European expert names very precisely: young players always look to their seniors as role models. If excessive contact is accepted at the professional level, it becomes "normal" below.

This is what I want to call "downward transmission". Football, culturally, does not flow upward. It flows downward. A ten-year-old at a provincial academy does not learn football culture from books. He learns from watching the V-League on television. He learns from watching how his idol tackles, how his idol reacts after being punished, and what his idol says in the post-match interview.

And this is where discipline at V-League level becomes a youth-development intervention, even though it was not designed to be one.

If a national-team star tackles heavily, is suspended four matches, returns and does the same thing two months later, what message is sent to thousands of children? Not "don't do that". But "doing that is fine, as long as you are famous enough".

This is what the expert calls a cultural problem, and what I call a signal problem. Every sanction is a signal. Every lenient sanction is a signal. Every inconsistent sanction is a signal. And those signals, accumulated, form a culture.

I spoke with a youth coach in a northern province who asked to remain anonymous. He told me in one short sentence: "At my club, when I teach the kids not to tackle hard, I have to face the parents. They say their children need to be tough to get a place".

He paused for a moment. Then he added: "I understand them. I was once like that too".

My pen needs no ink, only a gap. And that gap is the distance between what we tell children and what we reward them for.


Fourth cut: deterrence, or the question no one wants to answer

The European expert raised a question I think is the most important in the entire interview: if dangerous incidents keep recurring despite disciplinary measures, one must question the effectiveness of current penalties.

This is a systemic question, not a moral one. It is like the question an engineer asks when a bridge keeps collapsing: not "who drove over the bridge wrongly", but "what is wrong with the bridge's design".

The purpose of a penalty, according to the expert, is both punishment and prevention. And if a penalty fails to prevent, then it is only punishment. Punishment without prevention is a ritual. It satisfies public opinion for a week, then everything returns to normal.

I have tracked V-League sanctions for years. I record them. And I have noticed a pattern I am not sure the expert has seen: sanctions grow in length, but not in consistency.

A famous player's heavy tackle may earn four matches. A lesser-known player's similar tackle may earn two. A challenge causing serious injury may receive a lighter ban than a challenge causing no injury but occurring in a televised big match.

This inconsistency is a more serious problem than short bans. Because when punishment becomes unpredictable, players no longer know where the line is. And when there is no line, every behaviour is possible. They forget that a contract is something that can be read backwards. And a disciplinary system that cannot be read backwards is a system with no legs.

The expert stresses that penalties must be sufficiently deterrent and more consistent. I agree with the second part more strongly than the first. Because increasing the length of bans without increasing consistency only creates a disciplinary system that is randomly severe. And a randomly severe system is one in which players learn to gamble, not to comply.


Fifth cut: from Văn Hậu to Đình Bắc, reading an incident backwards

I want to return to specific incidents, because they are where abstract analysis gains flesh.

Văn Hậu received a four-match suspension after a heavy challenge on Doãn Ngọc Tân. He is a national-team player, a big name, a role model for thousands of children. He tackled heavily. He was punished. He returned.

This is where I want to see what statistics tables do not show: after returning, how did that player play? Did he change his tackling? Did he avoid situations he used to dive into? Or did he return with the same reflex, only now calculated more carefully to avoid punishment?

I have no data to answer that question scientifically. And I will not pretend I do. But I have eyes. And my eyes tell me that behavioural change, when it happens, usually comes from a player growing older and losing pace, not from a player learning a moral lesson.

This means pressure on young players is the most dangerous. And this is where the Đình Bắc story becomes noteworthy.

A young forward, ascending, taken down by two different players in two different situations. Tấn Sinh and Văn Sơn. This is not one accident, and not two independent accidents. This is a pattern: when a young player becomes dangerous, opponents find a way to make him no longer dangerous. Physically, if necessary.

I have seen this before, in other leagues. In Argentina, in some Asian leagues, in Africa. It is not a Vietnamese speciality. But where disciplinary systems are strong, targeted players are protected by referees, and targeting players are removed by sanctions. Where disciplinary systems are weak, targeted players learn to protect themselves, by playing safer, by not holding the ball in dangerous areas, by reducing their own creativity.

This is a tactical loss few mention. Vietnamese football may have lost part of a generation of young players' creativity because they learned that creativity has a price. Not a price in points. A price in bones.

My pen needs no ink, only a gap. And that gap is the space between the protection system and the reality of on-field violence.


Contrarian angle: why the expert's approach may still fall short

Now I need to say what I have not said.

I believe the European expert is right about the diagnosis. But I am not sure he is right about the remedy. And I am not sure we should agree with him as easily as we do.

Reason one: the "education" frame can neutralize individual responsibility. When we say a player tackles hard because he was taught wrong, we shift responsibility from the player to the system. This is analytically true. But it can become a moral excuse. A twenty-five-year-old player, with twenty-five years of life and fifteen years of football, is still an adult responsible for his behaviour. If we tell him "it's not your fault, it's the system's fault", we are teaching him a new lesson: no responsibility.

I have seen this in many other fields. When a negative phenomenon is explained entirely by the system, those who cause it tend to feel liberated. They say: "I am just a product of circumstance". And that sentence, in many cases, is true. But it is also a door to not having to change.

Reason two: the "education" frame assumes we know what to teach. But we do not. We know that hard tackling is wrong. But we do not know how to teach a twelve-year-old that hard tackling is wrong in a culture where hard tackling is rewarded. Education is not a process of transmitting knowledge. Education is a process of changing environments. And changing environments is far harder than opening a course for coaches.

Reason three, and perhaps most important: the "education" frame has a very long timeline, while the player-safety problem is urgent. If we say the solution is retraining youth coaches, and retraining takes ten years, then in those ten years, how many young players get injured? How many careers end before they begin?

This is what I call the "policy-patience gap". The fix is generational. But public opinion demands change within months. And within that gap, young players are still tackling, still being tackled.

So where is the European expert's approach right, and where is it insufficient?

It is right in that it points to the highest-leverage point: the quality of youth-coach training. If you want to change football culture, you must change those who teach that culture.

It is insufficient in that it ignores short-term measures that can protect players right now. Specifically: better protection for targeted players, more consistent and immediate sanctions, and a clear responsibility mechanism between the Federation and the league organizer.

And it is insufficient at one further point I want to stress: it does not mention money.


Second contrarian angle: the money question no one asks

I have worked in this profession long enough to know that in football, every problem eventually becomes a money problem. And I always carry a laptop full of data tables to prove it.

If we want a serious youth-coach training system, we need money. Money to pay instructors. Money to build curricula. Money to offer scholarships to young coaches in the provinces. Money to organize certification exams. Money to monitor and re-evaluate certificates.

Who pays? The Federation has a limited budget. Clubs have a more limited one. Private academies can pay, but they have no incentive to pay for a programme whose benefits cannot be measured in one season.

And this is where I want to mention an aspect interviews often skip: football is an economic sector, and investment decisions in this sector follow economic logic. If you want clubs to invest in coach training, you must make doing so economically beneficial. You must make clubs without licensed coaches pay a price. Directly, perhaps in cash. Indirectly, perhaps in image.

But doing so requires unity among stakeholders. And that unity does not exist. The European expert speaks of shared responsibility between the Federation and the league organizer. That is a diplomatic way of phrasing a less diplomatic problem: no one wants to take sole responsibility.

I have seen this before. In my investigations into financial fraud in football, the most common answer from stakeholders was "that is not our business". And when everyone says "that is not our business", in the end no one does anything. The responsibility gap is where systemic problems survive.


Third contrarian angle: the named players

There is one thing in the interview I think needs to be said clearly, though it is not the main topic: the named players.

Văn Hậu. Tấn Sinh. Văn Sơn. Đình Bắc. Doãn Ngọc Tân.

Five names on one page. Five careers. Five families.

I defend none of them. If they tackled hard, they must bear responsibility. But I know that in this industry, once a name is attached to an incident, that name follows the person through their entire career. And I know that public pressure does not distinguish between the perpetrator and the recipient.

Đình Bắc, a young forward, was targeted twice. He is a victim. But in an unhealthy media environment, a victim can be seen as someone not tough enough. I have seen this in many places. I have seen injured young players asked why they did not avoid the tackle, as if responsibility belonged to them.

The dressing room has no camera, but it has whispers. And one of the most toxic whispers is the one saying that the one in pain is the weak one.

If we want to change Vietnamese football culture, we must change not only how we teach players, but also how we speak about players. Because public opinion is part of the educational environment. And every time we turn a young player who was attacked into a symbol of weakness, we teach a new lesson to the next generation.


Looking back at history: this is not the first time

The European expert says anyone who has followed the V-League for years knows this is a long-standing feature, not a new phenomenon.

I confirm that. I have followed it for nearly twenty years. I have seen the cycles. Every season, a few big incidents. Every big incident, a round of debate. Every round of debate, a promise of reform. And every promise of reform, a silence afterward.

This makes me skeptical about the ability of a single interview to change everything. But it also makes me realize something else: the recurrence of the problem across generations of coaches and players shows it is not an individual problem. It is not a problem of one generation. It is a structural problem.

One generation of players tackled hard. The next generation tackled hard. The third generation tackled hard. When a phenomenon survives three generations, it is no longer behaviour. It is culture. And culture does not change through punishment. Culture changes by changing those who pass that culture on.


Another cut: technology and transparency

I want to mention a factor not in the interview but which I believe is important: technology and transparency.

Over the past decade, world football has undergone a data revolution. Every match, every phase, every referee decision can be recorded and analysed. Systems like VAR have changed how decisions are made. Motion-tracking systems have changed how clubs understand performance.

In the V-League, these technologies are appearing but have not been used systematically. And I think this has a direct consequence for on-field violence: when behaviours are not recorded, they are not counted. When they are not counted, they are not evaluated. And when they are not evaluated, they become normal.

A good data system would make negative behaviours visible. It would allow league managers to track trends, identify repeat-offender players, and assess the effectiveness of disciplinary measures. What you can measure, you can manage. What you cannot measure, you cannot manage.

The pandemic exposed what football had hidden: numbers. And now, when we talk about on-field violence, we are also talking about numbers we do not have. Fouls per match. Injuries per season. Days players miss through collision injuries. Recurrence rates among sanctioned players. The number of incidents referees miss.

These numbers do not exist. And their absence is part of the problem.


A signal from the Đình Bắc case itself

I want to linger a little longer on the Đình Bắc case, because it is a signal I believe has not been read correctly.

A young forward, ascending, targeted by two different players. This is not a story about an individual. This is a story about a system.

In professional football, there is a very clear logic: if you cannot stop a player by playing football, you can stop him another way. This logic exists in every league. But in leagues with strong disciplinary systems, the cost of using the other way exceeds its benefit. In leagues with weak disciplinary systems, the cost is lower. And when the cost is lower, the other way becomes the main way.

The worrying thing is that when the other way becomes the main way, young players learn to protect themselves. They will play safer. They will not hold the ball in dangerous areas. They will not attempt creative moves. And Vietnamese football will lose the players it could have had.

This is a loss no statistics table can measure. No data shows what did not happen. But it is a real loss, and it happens every day.


On the silence of the youth coaches

While writing this piece, I contacted many youth coaches. None agreed to speak publicly. A few agreed to speak anonymously. Others did not answer my messages.

This silence is data.

It shows that youth coaches know there is a problem but do not believe speaking out will help them. In an environment where coaches have little power and little protection, speaking out about a systemic problem is an act with high risk and low benefit.

I have seen this in many places. Silence is not a sign that there is no problem. Silence is a sign that the problem has grown too large to be spoken.

One youth coach told me: "If I say my kids tackle too hard because we lack methodology, then people will ask why we lack methodology. And I cannot answer that question without saying we have no licences".

He paused. Then he said: "And if I say I have no licence, then I am saying I am not competent enough".

That is a trap. And that trap is built by the system, not by individuals.


On the question the expert does not answer

The European expert, in his interview, raised many questions. But there is one he did not raise, and I think it is the most important: why do V-League clubs not invest in youth-coach training?

The obvious answer is: because they have no money. But that is an incomplete answer. Because V-League clubs also do not invest in many other things they need, and that is not because they have no money. It is because they have no pressure to invest.

In professional football, clubs invest in what they think will bring results. They invest in players, because players score goals. They invest in head coaches, because head coaches win matches. They do not invest in youth coaches, because youth coaches do not score goals and do not win matches in the current season.

This means youth-coach reform cannot come from clubs. It must come from the Federation, and it must include incentive and enforcement mechanisms. Clubs must be made to see that not investing in youth-coach training costs more than investing.

This is a political problem, not only a sporting one.


On timing and patience

I have learned one thing in this profession: timing is everything. A story told at the right moment can change everything. A story told at the wrong moment can be forgotten within a week.

The European expert's interview was published at an important moment: after a cluster of early-season violent incidents. This is when public attention is highest, and sources tend to be more open. I have learned to choose timing in my work. Crisis is when society pays most attention, and also when hard truths are easier to tell.

But I have also learned that public attention is a finite resource. It lasts a few weeks, sometimes months, then moves to another topic. And when attention moves on, systemic problems remain.

So the real question is not: will this interview change anything? The real question is: after the attention moves on, who will keep working?


On responsibility and inheritance

I want to close the analysis with a thought about responsibility and inheritance.

Football is one of the least consciously inherited industries. Clubs change coaches, federations change leadership, players change clubs. Very few people have an incentive to think about the next ten years, because they may not be in their position in ten years.

This is why structural problems in football tend to last. No one is responsible for them, because no one stays long enough to be responsible.

But there is one group with an incentive to think about the long-term future: youth coaches. They will stay. They will teach the next generation. They will continue their work for the next twenty years. And if we invest in them, we invest in the future. If we ignore them, we ignore the future.

This is why I think the European expert's proposal — focusing on youth-coach training — is right in direction. It is only insufficient on short-term measures. And it does not say enough about money.


Conclusion: a progressive question

I wrote this piece over several weeks, interviewed many people, re-read many old notes. And what I realized is: the V-League's on-field violence problem is not an individual problem. It is a problem of a system that has forgotten it is teaching.

Every match is a classroom. Every sanction is a lesson. Every forgiven challenge is a lesson. And Vietnamese football, whether it wants to or not, is teaching a generation of young players that physical force is a valid way to solve problems.

If that is true, the question is not how to punish harder. The question is: what do we want to teach, and who teaches it?

I have no answer. I only have a pen that needs no ink, and a gap large enough to write through.

And I will keep counting. Not goals. The challenges I believe are not accidents. Until that number stops rising.

Cầu thủ liên quan