VAR Official Who Erred in Manchester Derby Returns to Duty: A View from a Writer of Silences
Core answer: Matt Donohue, the VAR official who failed to disallow Erling Haaland's Manchester derby goal on September 13, returns as assistant VAR for Coventry vs. Fulham on Saturday. Key facts: 1) Donohue and assistant Blake Antrobus missed Enzo Fernández's offside interference in the build-up to Haaland's goal at Old Trafford. 2) Howard Webb said Donohue developed "tunnel vision" and needed team support to avoid it. 3) Donohue refereed Championship matches (Southampton vs. Bolton, Derby vs. Wrexham) during his three-round absence from Premier League duty. 4) The KMI panel voted 3-2 to back the VAR recommendation to send off Brighton's Pascal Struijk vs. Sunderland on October 10, but an independent commission later quashed the suspension. 5) The Premier League clarified that the KMI panel and the independent commission are separate bodies with different processes. Source: Original reporting, published October 2025. | Cross-checked: VuaBong.vn. Related Q&A: Q: Why was Donohue absent from Premier League matches? A: He was omitted for three match rounds after the derby error, officiating in the Championship instead. Q: What did the KMI panel decide on Struijk? A: The panel backed the VAR recommendation for a red card by a 3-2 vote, though the suspension was later overturned. Q: Who is Howard Webb? A: Webb is Pro Ref's chief refereeing officer and commented on Donohue's "tunnel vision."
In the tunnel at Old Trafford, after the final whistle, Matt Donohue stood still. No one filmed him. No one asked questions. There was only the yellow flicker of fluorescent lights and the sound of cleaners' footsteps. A month after that moment, his name reappears on the Premier League appointment list: assistant VAR for Coventry vs. Fulham this Saturday. People call it a return. I call it a silence filled with unanswered questions.
On September 13, in the Manchester derby at Old Trafford, Donohue and assistant Blake Antrobus failed to spot that Manchester City's Enzo Fernández was in an offside position and interfering with play in the phase leading to Erling Haaland's goal. That phase did not just change the score. It changed the way people look at the VAR system — a system designed to eliminate mistakes, but which produces new ones, more subtle, harder to see. Howard Webb, Pro Ref's chief refereeing officer, later admitted Donohue had developed "tunnel vision" — focusing only on whether Haaland was offside while forgetting that there were other eyes around him. Webb said: "It was the job of the team around Donohue to help pull him out of that tunnel." But in football, no one pulls anyone out of a tunnel. People just wait at the other end, or step in together.
Donohue did not appear in the next three match rounds. Antrobus returned earlier, as assistant referee for Newcastle vs. Aston Villa last Saturday. Donohue refereed in the Championship: Southampton vs. Bolton, then Derby vs. Wrexham on October 10. Those matches had no VAR. No screens. No voice from the control room. Just him, the ball, and 22 players. Perhaps that is the best way for a referee to relearn how to trust his own eyes — by being in a space where no one can correct him, and no one can blame him.
But the story does not stop at Donohue. That same week, the Key Match Incidents (KMI) panel — five people: three former players and coaches, one Premier League representative, one from Pro Ref — voted 3-2 to back the VAR recommendation to send off Brighton's Pascal Struijk in the match against Sunderland on October 10. Struijk was judged to have denied an obvious goalscoring opportunity. But later, an independent regulatory commission quashed the suspension, ruling it was a wrongful dismissal. Two bodies, two opposite conclusions, looking at the same phase. The Premier League then had to explain that the KMI panel and the independent commission are entirely separate entities with different purposes and processes. But to fans, that distinction does not matter. What they see is a player suspended, then cleared, while the referee is still there, still making mistakes, and still officiating.
I have spent years sitting in empty stadiums, recording the wind and the footsteps of cleaners. I learned that football is not just what happens on the pitch. It is also what happens in the tunnel, in the VAR room, in closed meetings no one records. When Donohue walked into the Old Trafford tunnel that night, he was not just a referee who made a mistake. He was a 33-year-old man who had perhaps spent his youth learning the laws, chasing phases of play, believing that technology would make him better. And then technology betrayed him. Not because it was wrong, but because it was right in a way humans could not keep up with.

There is something few notice: in the three rounds Donohue was absent, the Premier League did not lack referees. The system kept running. Matches went on. But mistakes continued. Struijk was still suspended and then cleared. Teams still protested. Managers still spoke. And fans still sat in the stands, looking up at the big screen, waiting for a decision they knew would never fully satisfy them. Donohue is just one link in that machine. The machine does not stop for a weak link. It just replaces it, or lets the old link fix itself in the dark.
I am not writing this to defend Donohue. I am writing to point out one thing: refereeing mistakes are not an individual problem but a systemic one — and how we handle mistakes is what shapes football culture. Donohue returns to duty not because he has fixed his error. He returns because the system needs him there. The Premier League needs enough officials to run 10 matches per round. Pro Ref needs to show it does not abandon referees after a mistake. And fans need someone to blame when their team loses. Donohue is the chosen one. Not because he deserves it, but because he is there.
In football, people often talk about moments of brilliance: a 90th-minute goal, an impossible save, a long-range strike into the net. But there is another kind of moment, less mentioned: the moment a referee walks into the VAR room, looks at the screen, and knows every decision will be dissected by millions. No one cheers for him. No one sings his name. There is only the voice in his earpiece and the eyes of his assistant. And then, when the whistle blows, he walks out through the tunnel, alone, with a document bag and a mind full of questions.
Donohue will be at Coventry on Saturday. Antrobus will be there, or at another ground. Struijk will return to Brighton's squad, or not. And fans will sit in the stands again, shout when there is a whistle, argue on social media again. And I, I will sit in a corner of a stadium again, recording what no one records. Because football is not just what happens on the pitch. It is also what happens in a referee's mind, when he knows he was wrong, and knows he will have to be right again next week.
There is a line I always carry: "The cheers ring in my head. The stadium is empty, but memory is never empty." Donohue probably has a stadium in his head too. And in that stadium, there is no VAR. Just him, the ball, and a belief that next time will be different. Will next time be different? I do not know. But I know that until the system changes, there will be other Donohues, other tunnels, and other silences. And the writer, like me, will stay, recording the breath of the ball before it rolls.
